The HD disc format war is over!

August 3, 2007

Actually, no it’s not. We’re nowhere near the end, yet countless fortune tellers seem to have called the winner. Let me share with you some facts and you’ll see how far we truly are from deciding on an HD disc format.

I’ll be honest. I’m one of those who have called the winner already, but TDG Research over at Digital Trends has convinced me otherwise. Check out the facts:

Yes, Blu-ray has a slight advantage over HD DVD when it comes to player count. For every 5 Blu-ray players, there’s only 1 HD DVD player, but out of the 1.5 million Blu-ray players, 1.4 million are PS3s. Recent research done by TDG found that only 40% of disc playing console owners use their consoles for movie playback. After all that number crunching, Blu-ray’s advantage isn’t as great as it appears.

In June of 2007 there were 1.8 million high-def players running wild in our homes. That’s a lot of players! Actually, no it’s not. It’s only 1.3% of of the 140 million stand-alone disc players in the US. There’s a lot of people left to buy HD players.

There are many companies that could jump in the format war at any moment that’ll turn the tides quite significantly, especially PC OEMs and the bigger players in disc sales, specifically Wal-mart, which owns 45% of the DVD sell-thru market, followed by Best Buy and Target. The fact that Blockbuster chose to sell only Blu-ray discs in its brick and mortar stores is really not a big deal at all.

While Blu-ray holds a bit of a lead in the HD format race, the lead is barely a quarter mile in a 25 mile marathon. Perhaps this holiday season will produce a significant lead in favor of one of the formats.

Be Sociable, Share!

4 Responses to “The HD disc format war is over!”

  1. owen:

    finelly someone gets whats actually going on and not taking a side but printing the acctual facts

  2. smoothn00dle:

    Out of touch! The problem is not the players. It is the software. HD-DVD just don’t have software except 10 yrs old movies.

    Blu-Ray this Christmas the trilogy: Spiderman3, Pirate3 and Sherk3. All blu-ray exclusive. No wonder Target and Wal-Mart go Blu-Ray exclusive, too. Just Exclusive HD-Dvd to death.

    Don’t play the number games. Exclusive is the problem not player attachment ratio.

  3. Joe Mama:

    Come on smoothnoodle, enough with the FUD. Yes Sony used creative wording to make it sound like Target chose Blu-ray over HD-DVD. But for some reason Target found it important enough to release their own statement clarrifying that Sony had simply paid them for prime isle space in their store and to stress that they will continue to carry both formats. This is very consistent with the author’s story here. If you like Blu-ray, thats great, but only reality is going to win the war for one of these formats.

  4. Mark G:

    Don’t forget the killer Disney releases, Kill Bill 1/2 and Pulp Fiction, only coming to Blu-Ray this year.

Leave a Reply:

Recent stories

Featured stories

RSS Windows news

RSS Mac news

RSS iPad news

RSS iPhone & Touch

RSS Mobile technology news

RSS Tablet computer news

RSS Buying guides

RSS PS3/Wii/Xbox 360

RSS Green technology

RSS Photography

Featured Content


Copyright © 2014 NS