Asus EeePC with 1GB memory and Windows XP reviewed
By Jonathan Schlaffer
I know reviews about the Asus EeePC have been cropping up all over the place but most of them revolve around the base install of Linux but we’ve got something different for you. When I received my Asus EeePC the first thing I did was replace the distro of Xandros with Windows XP. How does the Asus EeePC handle Windows XP, read on to find out.
The first thing to know is that installing Windows XP on the Asus EeePC requires a little more work than a standard PC would, the obvious difference being that you need an external optical drive in order to install an operating system but the manual is good about providing details though sometimes the translation (from Chinese?) to English is a bit off (but completely understandable).
Installing Windows XP on the Asus EeePC doesn’t take any more time than it does with a standard PC once it has started. After it’s finished insert the Asus support DVD to install the drivers, really, that’s one of the easiest steps though the ACPI driver can be a tad finicky.
With only a 4GB SSD to work with you don’t have much room left so one of the things the manual recommends is to compress hard drive space, I did so and with just Windows installed there is about 1.6GB of space left. Additional space can be added through the SD/SDHC card slot (which will sit flush with the computer).
There are three USB 2.0 ports, LAN, WiFi, VGA out and headphone/microphone connections.
The Asus EeePC ships with 512MB of memory but can support up to 1GB so the first thing to do (if you don’t mind voiding the warranty) is to replace the included 512MB module with a 1GB module as there is only one slot in the system. Part of the memory will be shared with the integrated Intel graphics of the GMA900 series.
As for the 7″ display, it is useable but is not exactly stellar, I think Asus could have squeezed a few more pixels in there instead of sticking with the 800 x 480 display that it currently uses. But, that would have increased costs.
I won’t lie here, people with big hands will absolutely hate the keyboard but if you have small hands or thin fingers (like me) then it won’t be too much of a problem but even those with small hands will still have to get used to it, either that or use an external USB keyboard with it.
The heart of the system is a 900MHz Celeron processor. I know what you’re thinking, how fast can it possibly be with a Celeron processor? Well, it is surprisingly speedy. It boots in about 30~45 seconds (no worse than a standard XP system) and once it is booted the speed of the SSD certainly helps things along.
But, it is not perfect. If you follow some of the suggestions in the manual, Windows will occasionally look for a file that may have been deleted to save space on the SSD, these can be safely ignored. It will also want to repair system files if you run the check for that, which should also be ignored. Sometimes Explorer will crash and third party firewalls seem to have a hard time on it but it’s not so bad and does not happen very often.
It’s not a bad first attempt by Asus to enter the low cost UMPC market and if that’s what you are in the market for, there is no better or cheaper option, prices only go up (for other models) from the $399 price of the Asus EeePC. Additional lower cost models and different colors are due out, including a black version, which was just released.
One with a 2GB SSD is due out but it’s hard enough squeezing Windows XP into 4GB, I wouldn’t want to try it with only 2GB of space.
To sum up,
Pros
Small and lightweight
Durable SSD (instead of a traditional hard drive)
More storage can be added through use of SD or SDHC memory cards
Speedy enough to run Windows XP (with additional memory)
Produces little, if no heat (it does have a small cooling fan)
Windows XP drivers included
Relatively low cost UMPC
Has webcam and speakers on side of display
Cons
Screen could be of higher resolution but is sufficiently bright with plenty of settings
Though the SSD is durable it is too small to contain both the OS and a lot of programs
Included memory isn’t sufficient to run Windows XP
Adding more memory voids warranty
Windows XP slightly unstable after install (but totally useable)
Windows XP is currently not an option though users can install it themselves
Optical drive extra
You’ll have to judge some of those for your own, I wouldn’t expect such a tiny and not to mention low cost computer to include an optical drive and I might have been a little bit picky on some issues but I’m just calling it as I see it.
Lastly, it is possible to buy a more capable full sized laptop with Windows XP or Vista, it is not possible to buy such a small computer, any cheaper but opting to install Windows XP will set you back the cost of that operating system plus an external optical drive if you don’t already have one.
The Asus EeePC ships to most customers with the default customized Xandros Linux (this does not mean it will necessarily fully support other distros so keep that in mind).
Related:






Stumble It!

November 25th, 2007
For his next trick, Jonathan drives finishing nails with a sledge hammer, attaches drywall screws with pliers, and makes toast with a blow torch.You finally had a chance to test Linux with a computer that had it preinstalled and tweaked by the manufacturer. Instead we get a review of a last generation OS installed on hardware it wasn’t optimized to use to the fullest. When can we expect a review with MS Office installed?
November 26th, 2007
Agreed, jeez Windows XP is 6 years old, just let it go. I can’t bear using an OS that is 2 years old, let alone 6.
It doesn’t get any less ugly as well does it?
November 26th, 2007
But those reviews are dime a dozen, aren’t they? Many people were wondering how it would handle XP and here it is. It is also capable of running Vista but I wasn’t about to go that far.
November 27th, 2007
Fair enough :-) Nice review by the way, so don’t let us nasty people get you down
November 27th, 2007
Hey jonathon, Nice review. Planning on getting myself one of these come christmas (im 14). Ive been thinking of sticking xp on one of these. Ive got a 250GB WD passport so space is no issue.
Could you give me a bit more info about the RAM? I have heard that it is DDR2-400 SODIMM but is this correct?
Thanks
Adam
November 28th, 2007
How long do you think that Solid State Drive is going to last with Windows constantly writing to it?
Less that a year I would guess.
The system was designed to use Linux for a reason.
But have fun breaking it if that is what you want to do.
November 28th, 2007
When the only tool you know is a hammer, I guess that makes everything a nail.
December 4th, 2007
Why on earth would you bother putting Windows XP on it for goodness sake!
December 10th, 2007
I love XP on my asus, i wrote a how to on it here:
http://www.seanpercival.com/blog/index.php/2007/12/10/how-to-install-windows-xp-on-the-asus-eee-pc/
January 30th, 2008
I bought the EeePC with the sole intention of putting XP onto it. I want a cheap PC that I can leave in my bag and use a 3G card to access work Citrix. This is PERFECT for me… (the 3G cards drivers are XP only)
March 5th, 2008
I was thinking of purchasing this and getting an external hardrive. I have a dell inspiron now but really only use it for the things available on the Asus. How practical is this? (and for those not very technology oriented, how easy?)
April 4th, 2008
I use the factory Xandros Linux on my eeepc and get online with it using my verizon cell phone as the modem to connect to the data network. It connects via the USB cable and uses the default land-line dialer to connect using the cell phone. Where you input the phone number, you use #777. The linux dialer does not look for a dial tone so it works 100% of the time and has done so since I first tried it. This means Windows is not the only option.
May 11th, 2008
Hey, to get the Full resolution on your EEEPC go over to hackaday, search for eeepc someones made an alternate driver for xp,. works fine on mine :)!
May 30th, 2008
It is possible to install windows Xp on the 2nd SDHC drive?
July 9th, 2008
I purchased the ASUS EEPC 4G Linux. I hoped my PowerPoint and HTML files from my XP laptop would work under Linux. No problem with HMTL and PowerPoint display okay in OpenOffice although the custom animations need to be re-jigged. Overall build quality is seems good. I am new to Linux and miss the desktop. However, biggest drawback is connecting wirelessly using a Belkin GPLUS MIMO router. Lots on the internet about the ‘pending’ problem, but ASUS and Belkin now tell me they are not compatible. I wish I had known.
July 25th, 2008
I’ve got an eepc 900 with XP. I’m happy with it. An external optical drive is not really needed to install (all) software. If your original CD or DVD can be copied to an image file, like Nero’s (extension .nrg), all you need to do is install Nero ImageDrive in the eeepc and run the disk image file from an external pen drive or from the extra memory card. I guess any other disk-image program might work.
Of course this won’t work with the first W XP installation. But I wonder if the eeepc recognizes a pen drive where you could copy the entire W XP disk (not in image format) for installation.