Photographer Lane Hartwell gets web 2.0 ‘Bubble’ video pulled

December 15, 2007

Photographer Lane Hartwell gets web 2.0 ‘Bubble’ video pulledWe’re all aware that with the explosive growth in the Internet, blogging, and sites such as YouTube, copyright theft has seen a bit of an upsurge over the last few years. Some people let it go, but some choose to fight back, such as photographer Lane Hartwell.

A few weeks ago, a video entitled ‘Here Comes Another Bubble’ started making its merry way around the Internet, taking on the viral voracity needed to turn just another YouTube video in to a phenomenon.

The video was an accompaniment to a spoof song by a San Francisco based group called ‘The Richter Scales’. The song was about the web 2.0 bubble currently building up a head of steam, and mocked the last market crash.

It was a great video, and a brilliantly funny yet truthful look at the current trend, the only problem was, it turns out that some of the images used in the video weren’t copyright free, and one of the owners took exception to this.

Photographer Lane Hartwell reportedly flew in to a fit of rage when she saw one of her images being flashed on screen for a second, and made a copyright claim which eventually prompted YouTube to pull the clip of its site.

She told Wired News, who she works for amongst others:

I wasn’t upset by the video itself, [but] I thought, where does somebody just get the right to take this? It is stealing, I’m not a charity…. This is my living.”

The freelance photographer, who has been a victim of copyright theft many times in the past, got so fed up with this final straw, that she also changed her Flickr account to private, taking over 5,000 images out of the public domain.

Of course, Hartwell is entitled to defend her images, but on this occasion I think she is wrong, although I’m sure the publicity she has elicited from it hasn’t hurt. The band considered the video a parody, and so thought it would be protected under the fair use policy in the copyright laws, and I agree with them.

The video was massively popular, having been viewed hundreds of thousands of times on YouTube, and to see it removed over a one second glimpse of a photo rankles. If that covers her under copyright law, then I think the policies should be looked at again, as it seems like overkill to me.

I wanted to use a picture of Hartwell to put alongside this article, but didn’t want to risk being accused of thievery, so you’ll have to make do with a big C instead.

Be Sociable, Share!

2 Responses to “Photographer Lane Hartwell gets web 2.0 ‘Bubble’ video pulled”

  1. Ole Juul:

    I agree with the author, the whole copyright thing has gone too far. However I do beleive that “copyright theft”, as the name implies, is when copyright is stolen. When something is stolen, the original owner no longer has the item in question. From what I understand, this rarely happens with copyright and, according to the story, it did not happen here. More often, as in this case, the photographer still owns, and posesses, the copyright. It was merely infringed. That is why she was able to act the way she did.

  2. Elena:

    I’m glad someone wrote this. The reasoning behind copywriting is to ensure you are appropriately compensated for your work and contributions. So, it stands to stands to reason that this woman wanted money for her photo being flashed for a millisecond. Fine, understandable. But to have the video, which was rather well done (hence it’s quickly widespread popularity) and pretty intelligent (my boss was the one that sent it to me) seems rather hypocritical given her supposed stance as an artist. But then again she is just trying to make her living… Lane, maybe you should have tried retail or something…

    If we put a picture of her face with a big x over it on the internet, that’s original artwork, right?

Leave a Reply:

Recent stories

Featured stories

RSS Windows news

RSS Mac news

RSS iPad news

RSS iPhone & Touch

RSS Mobile technology news

RSS Tablet computer news

RSS Buying guides

RSS PS3/Wii/Xbox 360

RSS Green technology

RSS Photography

Featured Content


Copyright © 2014 NS