New UK hacking laws make ‘hacking tools’ illegal

January 3, 2008

New UK hacking laws make ‘hacking tools’ illegalNew computer crime laws for the UK are currently being fine tuned before hopefully being passed in to law later this year. However, some of the measures intended to punish hackers harder than than they currently are could be used to criminalise people legally working in the IT industry.

The UK has needed a thorough update of it’s outdated computer crime laws for years now, and the Computer Misuse Act which was included in the Police and Justice Act 2006 is intended to do just that. Amongst the new measures, are increases of the maximum penalty for hacking offences up to ten years, and denial of service offences made unambiguously illegal.

The problem part of the new bill, expected to come in to effect by May 2008, is the banning of developing, owning, or distributing what are being described as “hacker tools”. The industry has strongly criticised the wording, and universal targeting of the measure, and the application of this new crime could put system administrators and security consultants.

People working in the IT industry often use these legitimate tools to test system vulnerabilities in company systems. If the law is taken to the letter, these same people who are trying to stop hackers from breaking in to closed networks, could be charged.

As The Register points out:

“The distinctions between, for example, a password cracker and a password recovery tool, or a utility designed to run denial of service attacks and one designed to stress-test a network, are subtle. The problem is that anything from nmap through wireshark to perl can be used for both legitimate and illicit purposes, in much the same way that a hammer can be used for putting up shelving or breaking into a car.”

That may seem like a simple explanation but it’s a good example of how normal people could again be criminalised by some bad wording in a new law intended to stop real criminals from flourishing.

After the criticism, the government, via the CPS (Crown Prosecution Service) has issued some guidelines on how to read the rules. These establish that to be convicted, the developer of a tool would have to be shown to intend to use it for a criminal activity.

Although these new guidelines will help, the new set of rules does seem to be a bit of a mess, and it remains to be seen what, if any, real difference this all makes when it becomes law in the UK.

Be Sociable, Share!

5 Responses to “New UK hacking laws make ‘hacking tools’ illegal”

  1. BS:

    As long as it is not the government of the day defines what is a criminal activity – I recall a Labour Home Secretary defining a subversive as anyone who causes problems for the government. So an investigative journalist, if there are any left, could be arrested for using a password recovery tool on hteir own computer on the grounds that he intends to use it ti firther subversive activities.

    Don’t laugh, I am told public criticism of UK government policies has already been made illegal.

    The article says:

    “After the criticism, the government, via the CPS (Crown Prosecution Service) has issued some guidelines on how to read the rules. These establish that to be convicted, the developer of a tool would have to be shown to intend to use it for a criminal activity.”

  2. TheDotMaster:

    The government will never win. We are the people. Our crime is that of curiosity. Our loss is our freedom. Hacking is a skill not for the lazy, nor the unintelligent. It takes a honed eye to see an exploit. It takes a sharp mind to use it. Exploit code, not people – we are anonymous. Expect us.

  3. Brian:

    LULZ to the above. You make anons look bad.

  4. Brian:

    LULZ to the above. You make anons look bad.

  5. jack:

    the goverment WILL never stop everyone but it requires a lot of skill to make a tool and use it to great effect but it is so anoying having to reboot the computer after it has been effected by it.

Leave a Reply:


Recent stories

Featured stories

RSS Windows news

RSS Mac news

RSS iPad news

RSS iPhone & Touch

RSS Mobile technology news

RSS Tablet computer news

RSS Buying guides

RSS PS3/Wii/Xbox 360

RSS Green technology

RSS Photography

Featured Content

Archives

Copyright © 2014 Blorge.com NS