Google backing net neutrality – developing ISP throttling detector tools

June 15, 2008

Google backing net neutrality - developing ISP throttling detector toolsEver since it was discovered that American ISP Comcast was throttling BitTorrent and peer-to-peer traffic last year, net neutrality has been a hot topic for discussion. Google is already known to be in favour of net neutrality, but is now ramping that support up with development of tools to ensure ISPs play fairly.

Last summer, Comcast was found to be penalizing subscribers of its broadband service who downloaded excessively from BitTorrent and other peer-to-peer clients. Since then, it has come to light that many ISPs have followed suit, not only in the US, but around the world, and the big losers are the customers who are seeing their so-called unlimited services severely limited.

It was recently rumored that Comcast is planning on further punishing heavy users (and consequently all users) by introducing metered bandwidth use, and monthly caps. Meanwhile, in the UK, the CEO of Virgin media, the second largest British ISP caused uproar by claiming that “this net neutrality thing is a load of bollocks.”

So with the ISPs standing firm behind the idea that they have the right to penalize heavy users, the ordinary broadband user needs a big-name, high-profile champion. Step forward Google.

Google already backs the idea of net neutrality, which it refers to as broadband neutrality, but according to The Register, the company is now ramping up its support by developing tools to help ordinary users test to see whether their ISP is throttling their service or not.

Richard Whitt, Senior Policy Director for Google announced the plans during a panel discussion at Santa Clara University:

We’re trying to develop tools, software tools…that allow people to detect what’s happening with their broadband connections, so they can let [ISPs] know that they’re not happy with what they’re getting – that they think certain services are being tampered with.

If the broadband providers aren’t going to tell you exactly what’s happening on their networks, we want to give users the power to find out for themselves..

However, as Hot Hardware reports, it wasn’t always clear which side of the net neutrality divide Google was going to be on. In late 2005 when the idea of ISPs charging some customers extra first came up, Google discussed the issue:

We were pretty well known on the internet. We were pretty popular. We had some funds available. We could essentially buy prioritization that would ensure we would be the search engine used by everybody. We would come out fine – a non-neutral world would be a good world for us.

Luckily, both common sense and idealism then kicked in, and Google made its choice for good.

It’s not known when these tools will be made available, or how they will operate, but it is known that Google engineers have been working on the project for quite some time. With Google firmly in the net neutrality corner, the ISPs should be running scared.

However, if the tools take too long to arrive, they may prove worthless, as every ISP will then be throttling bandwidth, and it will be too little, too late to do anything about it.

Be Sociable, Share!

5 Responses to “Google backing net neutrality – developing ISP throttling detector tools”

  1. Daniel J. Doughty:

    Google has a pretty good history of releasing relevant products and they’re obviously not afraid of offering beta services, so I’d be surprised if it takes too long for them to release them. And even if they release them after capping starts to occur, it appears that the ISPs are attempting to use this a a way to differentiate their offerings. Time Warner is considering selling more expensive plans to some customers who use a lot of bandwidth. In my local region, Kansas City, we have a FiOS competitor called Everest and WiMax may become a reality in a year or so.

  2. Jamal Jomaa:

    Great idea i experienced simaliar problems on this so called “throttling issue”. The other day I was downloading 4 or 5 different things simultaneously and all of the sudden my connection cut out. I then rest my modem and continued to download again only to notice that my connection in vuze was cut in half. I contacted my ISP and told them what was going on and that it seemed like my line was being throttled, after I got off the phone with them my connection jumped up to speed again and noticed that the health was once green again as appose to the yellow I was getting before contacting my ISP.

    I do definetly believe they are throttling certain (power) user’s that are constantly downloading and using up bandwidth. This is not fair at all, it is none of there business what I do with my line that i pay for every month.

    This tool is definetly needed!

  3. Shauna @ Kansas 4G Wireless:

    Hello there, just doing some research for my Kansas 4g site. Truly more information that you can imagine on the web. Not quite what I was looking for, but good site. Have a nice day.

  4. catcher jewelry:

    I just couldn’t depart your website before suggesting that I actually loved the usual information an individual provide on your visitors? Is gonna be back often to check up on new posts

  5. Internet:

    I am now not certain the place you are getting your information, but good topic. I must spend some time learning more or working out more. Thanks for excellent information I used to be searching for this info for my mission.

Leave a Reply:

Recent stories

Featured stories

RSS Windows news

RSS Mac news

RSS iPad news

RSS iPhone & Touch

RSS Mobile technology news

RSS Tablet computer news

RSS Buying guides

RSS PS3/Wii/Xbox 360

RSS Green technology

RSS Photography

Featured Content


Copyright © 2014 NS