Touch-screen throwdown: HTC Touch Diamond, iPhone 3G, or Samsung Instinct?
The good news for those who haven’t adopted the iPhone yet is that the rest of the market is scrambling to keep up and deliver new handsets to challenge the quickly growing dominance of Apple’s wonder handset. The bad news is that now you’ll have to actually decide which one to buy!
First off, if you’re looking for some sort of comprehensive hardware review, you’re looking in the wrong place. Certainly, hardware plays a large roll in how handsets perform and in what they deliver, but I’d prefer we take a look at the end result — how the perform and stand up to each other.
As these handset manufacturers must have forgotten to ship my courtesy test units out to me in a timely fashion, we’ll have to go off what others in the industry have seen. First up we have the HTC Touch Diamond, the sexy new handset not yet released in the U.S. Unlike its rather unattractive predecessor, the HTC Touch, the Touch Diamond is just pretty to look at, and pretty to use, it would seem.
The Touch Diamond, like its two competitors, has no keyboard, and runs the Windows Mobile 6.1 interface. Though I’m not the biggest fan of Windows Mobile, the Touch Diamond runs HTC’s unique TouchFlo 3D GUI, which is about as sexy as they come. Though the iPhone’s GUI is smooth and sexy, TouchFlo 3D doesn’t look to copy it — if you are interested in seeing it in action, here’s a video.
The Touch Diamond is powerful, has a sexy interface, and is thankfully not one of the handsets looking to replicate the iPhone to the T.
Next up is the Samsung Instinct, a handset that’s selling like hotcakes on the Sprint network. Unlike the Touch Diamond, the Instinct does look to replicate the success of the iPhone with a very similar GUI and operating system. However, that doesn’t mean the Instinct doesn’t have merit.
To the contrary, the Instinct takes advantage of many of the iPhone’s strengths like visual voicemail and take it a step further. Where the iPhone has no video recording, the Instinct does. The Instinct does streaming TV — the iPhone doesn’t. The Instinct allows for horizontal text messaging, where the iPhone requires you to type on a squeezed vertical keyboard. The Instinct is smaller than the iPhone. The Instinct also has GPS, a selling point for the iPhone 3G. If you’re looking for a video of the interface, it is your lucky day.
Another strong advantage to the Instinct is that it runs on Sprint’s CDMA network. CDMA generally has more consistent reception around the U.S. than many GSM networks (like the iPhone’s AT&T network).
Last, but certainly not least, is the forthcoming iPhone 3G. For those who don’t know what the iPhone offers, what rock have you been living under, and why did you emerge to read this article? However, the iPhone 3G does offer some new functionality, mainly a new fleet of downloadable applications and GPS. Perhaps most significantly, the iPhone 3G will run on AT&T’s 3G data network (surprise surprise). Beyond that, the iPhone 3G now has business “push” technology that was keeping many businesses from switching to the handset from the business-popular Blackberry.
It is quite a statement that the other two handsets are competitors’ responses to Apple’s iPhone, so you should know right off the bat that the iPhone is the industry standard for excellence in touch-screen cellular technology. However, many consider the iPhone’s only major drawback is that it is exclusively offered by AT&T. Though AT&T does have one of the largest customer bases, those customers were acquired through acquisitions, not necessarily by having stellar quality.
Furthermore, AT&T is notorious for having call issues. Many are upset that Verizon didn’t jump on the opportunity to host the iPhone, as AT&T has a lockdown on the handset for quite some time.
Still, the iPhone 3G, coming in at $199 for the base handset, might be enough to convince those who can’t stand to wait for the it to become available on other networks.
And that is where other touch handsets like the HTC Touch Diamond, Samsung Instinct and others come in. Though many were afraid that iPhone knockoffs were going to be just that, the fact of the matter is that competitors like the Touch Diamond and the Instinct bring innovation to the market where the iPhone 3G fails to capitalize on continued success. For those who can’t live with being on the AT&T network, don’t worry. There are viable alternatives at good prices, and soon enough, the entire industry will be delivering what Apple birthed.
Related Posts:
June 27th, 2008
Hi,
The article seems to be OFF. Doesn’t even compare each other nor elaborating further. Its just like watching News, telling you that iPhone, Sprint Samsung,and Touch Diamond is coming. Period.
P.S.
In an article, dont ever say this “or those who don’t know what the iPhone offers, what rock have you been living under”
People might new to the phone or iPhone industry and/or don’t have much time to waste for research.
Long live the Prince!
June 27th, 2008
“The iPhone does streaming TV — the iPhone doesn’t.” One of these should be “Instinct” (the first?) Hello editors? Also, the main issue for consumers like me is PRICES. While exact figures may be unavailable- how about estimates? Also availability and service (I assume this may be where iPhone dominates)
June 27th, 2008
This article needs better writing and more objectively, better editing:
“The iPhone does streaming TV — the iPhone doesn’t.”
June 27th, 2008
Thank you for the comments. Our editorial staff hasn’t been around to this article, it would seem, so I have corrected it accordingly. Apologies for inconsistencies. The article wasn’t intended to a a direct breakdown of every feature; it was intended to be more broad and opinionated. As it stands, there isn’t a standing price on the Touch Diamond as no carrier in the U.S. is currently offering it. The iPhone 3G is priced at $199 and $299 for the different models, and Sprint users can purchase the Instinct for $199 with a rebate.
September 6th, 2008
Its funny how you make fun of those who don’t know about the iPhone, but did you know that HTC is the standard for smartphones worldwide? Apple is trying to capitalize and continue the successs that HTC has accomplished with multiple phones, long before iPhone was born. The iPhone is an excellent option for those entering the smartphone market, but is far from been a complete solution. IPhone 3G? we’re almost close to 3.5 or 4 generation data transmission; push email is the standard long before iPhone 1; HTC Touch was the first touchscreen phone. Apple saw the potential behind this phones and came up with the simplify iPhone: beautiful interface with cripple functionality. Now iPhone 3G: more eye-candy with still old technology. Please give the credit to whom it belongs.
September 13th, 2008
Brand new Mobile phone Plasma tv , Laptop game at cheap price come with complete accessories with one year international warranty.
Email address : mary_sales005@hotmail.com
NINTENDO WII…….$250USD
NOKIA N95 8GB….$400USD
IPHONE 16GB……$350USD
iPHONE 8GB……..$300USD
IPOD 32GB………$350USD
NOKIA N96………$500USD
PS3 60GB……….$300USD
SAMSUNG SGH-U900………..$300USD
SONY ERICSSON XPERIA X1…….$450USD
AND MANY MORE…………
FULL SPECIFICATION FOR APPLE IPHONE 8GB
Display Type 16M colors
Size 480 x 320 pixels
Camera Resolution 2MP
Video Yes
Flashlight No
Connectivity GPRS Yes
HSDPA No
EDGE Yes
3G Yes
WiFi Yes
Bluetooth Yes
A2DP No
USB Yes
Ringtones Type yes
Memory
Card slot no
Internal user memory 8gb
Battery
Stand-by time Up to 250 hours
Talk time Up to 8 hours
Features Messaging SMS, Email
FM radio No
Games No
Speaker phone Yes
Operating System OS X v10.4.8
Touch-screen Yes
General Network GSM 850 / GSM 900 / GSM 1800 / GSM 1900
Announced 2007, January
Status Available
Size Dimensions 115 x 61 x 11.6 mm
Weight 135 g
Display Type Touchscreen, 16M colors
Size 320 x 480 pixels, 3.5 inches
Multi-touch input method
Accelerometer sensor for auto-rotate
Proximity sensor for auto turn-off
Ringtones Type Polyphonic, MP3
Customization Download
Vibration Yes
3.5 mm headset jack
Memory Phonebook Advanced, Photocall
Call records Yes
Card slot No
4/8 GB shared memory
Data GPRS Yes
HSCSD No
EDGE Yes
3G No
WLAN Wi-Fi 802.11b/g
Bluetooth Yes, v2.0
Infrared port No
USB Yes, v2.0
Features OS Mac OS X v10.4.8
Messaging SMS, MMS, Email, Instant Messaging
Browser HTML (Safari)
Games Yes
Camera 2 MP, 1600×1200 pixels, video
Google Maps
Widgets support
iPod audio/video player
PIM including calendar, to-do list
Photo browser/editor
Voice memo
Integrated handsfree
Battery Standard battery, Li-Ion
Talk time Up to 5 h
WE MAKE SHIPPMENT VIA UPS OR FEDEX EXPRESS OR DHL EXPRESS IN 2 DAYS AFTER CONFIRMATION OF PAYMENT………
Email address : mary_sales005@hotmail.com
mary_enquiry005@hotmail.com
January 8th, 2011
———————————————————–
I have been studying your posts in the course of my smoke break, and I’ve to admit the entire article has been very informative and very properly written. I believed I would allow you realize that for some reason this blog does not display properly in IE eight. I would like Microsoft would cease upgrading stuff. I have a question for you personally. Would you mind swapping blog roll links? That would be truly neat!