Music lovers still prefer CDs over digital downloads
By Dave Parrack
The music industry is rapidly evolving, moving from a time when sales were guaranteed and the Internet and file-sharing didn’t exist to a future with multiple revenue strands coming from all directions. Many people think digital downloads are the future of the business, but it seems that the majority of people still prefer buying and using physical formats.
The iPod and personal media players, as well as the Internet, changed the way we think about and consume music. All of a sudden it wasn’t a physical commodity like a vinyl record or audio tape but an electronic file to be shared and stored.
The music industry has struggled to accept this change, being slow to take advantage of digital downloads and streaming music services. Only now is it starting to embrace the obvious future. But it seems consumers are also resistant to the change.
According to The Telegraph, a recent survey of 1,000 music lovers by MusicAlly showed that the vast majority still prefer buying CDs to digital downloads. A whopping 73 percent of the people questioned are still happy buying CDs. And this isn’t a generational thing either as a still impressive 66 percent 14-to-18 year olds prefer CDs to digital formats.
Tim Walker, chief executive of The Leading Question, the research division responsible for carrying out the survey, said:
Digital is still the future but rumors of the death of the CD are premature. The continued popularity of the CD should be looked upon as an opportunity. We believe that labels and online stores could and should be doing more to build on music fans’ familiarity with CDs to provide them with additional digital content and to use the CD as a bridge into the digital world. Music fans have spoken and digital is evidently not the clear cut replacement to the physical CD.
Interestingly, the same people who stream music online from a paid source such as Napster are the ones spending more money on CDs every month. So rather than one method of listening to music replacing another, it seems as though music lovers will consume music in any and every way possible.
At the end of last year, there were calls from some parties for the music industry to ditch the CD altogether in favor of a totally digital future. But as I said at the time, you cannot enforce your will on market forces as that just builds resentment on the part of the consumers you are trying to sell to. Which doesn’t help either side.
Digital downloads are clearly the future, for games, television, and movies as well as for music, but it’ll take time for us all to abandon the physical formats we’re used to using. There’s an indescribable feeling you get from purchasing a new CD, video game, or DVD that you just don’t experience with a digital download. Until that fades then CDs and the like are here to stay.
Related:





Stumble It!

July 20th, 2009
Consumers are smart enough to recognize that the quality of streaming and even downloaded music is still crap compared to CD. Plus you can play that CD anywhere, via various DRM schemes they have locked up the content you download/stream so it is too hard for the average person to transport. Plus as the recent Amazon ebook fiasco illustrates, there is much about DRM’d digitally distributed content to worry about, such as revocation. Just pop a CD in a player and it works, no fuss no muss.
July 20th, 2009
I’m happy to hear this, but then why are CD sales so low?
July 20th, 2009
Because the quality of many modern releases stinks. Too overproduced, not much originality, too focused on commercial viability instead of artistic creativity.
July 20th, 2009
You can sell your used CDs if you are tired of them. You can’t do that with your digital downloads.
In some cases, CDs are a better deal than digital downloads. I have seen The Beatles #1 CD selling for as low as $9.99 around the holidays. You cannot legally purchase the Beatles on digital download.
But for buying just one song, digital downloads have the advantage….even though you can’t resell them.
July 21st, 2009
DavidB, I think you will find that the vast majority of Download services are now DRM free, so you can use them where ever and whenever you want (note: this does not apply to streaming or subscription services), so they offer the same (or possibly even more) portability as a CD does. What downloads don’t offer is the value added content that CDs have, such as cover art, notes & lyrics, and often added media content such as videos or images. Plus CDs have a considerably higher sound quality and a resale value.
July 22nd, 2009
I’d like to take exception to Tim Walker (quoted in the article above) who described CDs as a “bridge into the digital world”.
Has he failed to realise that CD is actually digital? Or that the digital world arrived with the advent of CDs to consumers?
August 28th, 2009
I agree with Ralph. For me collecting music cd’s of your idol, feels like heaven plus the fact that they include some pics. This is just like collecting Cd’s of world of warcraft and soon will be collecting their mags plus the Aion online.
@John, maybe because of the competition with video game industry, actually sales of video games also drop.